Photo of the Blue Marlin Bar & Grill for Shopping
  • 439 Loraine Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-7427


When you combine Put-in-Bay Ohio’s most popular pool & swim up bar and characterize it on the latest fashion shirt or sweatshirt the results are some of the most in-demand Put-in-Bay clothing out there! The Blue Marlin Bar & Grill shirt shop is located in the lobby of the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center just one block off the main strip. Our shirts have from mild to wild designs and a large variety of sizes. Stop by for a cocktail, a swim, lunch or for some really cool shirts!

Picture of shopping at the Butterfly house Put-in-Bay
  • 979 Catawaba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-2446


Inside the Perry’s Family Fun Center you’ll find the Butterfly House. Walk through this calming oasis as butterflies gently fly around you. Here you can find some great, unique gifts many of which are butterfly related. Families are encouraged to shop and enjoy the free film about butterflies. Spread your wings at the Butterfly House at Put-in-Bay.

  • 170 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-2920


Satisfy your sweet tooth shopping at The Candy Bar, located on Delaware Ave in downtown Put-in-Bay. Options include a multitude of candy, homemade fudge, taffy, and chocolates. Take a step back in the future with the great assortment of novelty candies. We have an ice cream shop that sells ice cream, shakes, sundaes, etc. Surely the sweetest bar on the Bay, The Candy Bar, is sugar central on Put-in-Bay.

Picture of a place to go shopping at Put-in-Bay The Bucket Shop
  • 228 Delaware Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-2323


Within the famed Roundhouse Bar Put-in-Bay, you’ll find that quirky gift at the Bucket Shop. Come and take your vows for a mock day marriage certificate. Don’t worry there are divorce forms too! Get a t-shirt to commemorate your status as a bucket head. Say hello to our staff when you’re there, just look for the guy with the hair! This is one of the most fun shops on Put-in-Bay.

Picture of the Carriage House Shopping Store at Put-in-Bay
  • 160 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
  • 419-285-2212


The premier souvenir spot at Put-in-Bay, the Carriage House’s shopping selection is vast. There are over 600 items that bear the wonderful “Put-in-Bay” name. Also, there is a large collection of name personalized items, including shot glasses and stationary. Quirky hats, ping pong balls and rubber ducks are but a few of the finds at the Carriage House. Find us across from Harbor Village on Delaware Ave. in Downtown Put-in-Bay.

Picture of the Chocolate Cafe Put-in-Bay
  • 820 Catawba Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-2268


The name alone will get your mouth watering. The Chocolate Cafe and Chocolate Museum at Put-in-Bay has a multitude of items relating to this favorite snack of many. The gift shop has trinkets, t-shirts and unique gifts for all of your chocalate lovers. Decadent chocolate and ice cream is also available for your delight.

Picture of the Country House Shopping Store
  • 246 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-3104


The Country House is home to a great assortment of fine house wares and gifts that are reminiscent of the grape vineyards and winemaking tradition of Put-in-Bay. There are also many other great gift ideas souvenirs to commemorate your trip to the Island. Located in downtown Put-in-Bay across from DeRivera Park.

Picture of Compass Point Shopping at Put-in-Bay
  • 420 Langram Road Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-6887


The Compass Pointe Shops are located next to the Put-in-Bay Post Office and feature a wide variety of fine gifts, apparel and more. There are multiple great shops in one location including Dock 421, the Little Store, Happy Holidays, Home Port and Sadies. The adjacent Island hardware Store also has a nice selection of gifts!

Photo of the Del Sol Shopping Outlet at Put-in-Bay
  • 185 Toledo Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-1111


Be amazed by the color changing magic of Del Sol. Located in Harbor Square Village in downtown Put-in-Bay, Del Sol has shirts, hats, visors, shorts, jewelry, sunglasses and many other items with the color-changing ability when exposed to the sunshine! This location is the only Del Sol Retailer in Ohio. Bring the family and witness the power of the sun!

Picture of Frosty Bar Gift Shopping at Put-in-Bay
  • 252 Delaware Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-3278


A place synonomous with a cold beer and hot pizza, Frostys has been bringing its flavor to Put-in-Bay for over 50 years. The gift shop has a variety of items bearing their recognizable logo. T-shirts, sweatshirts, and glasses are but of the few choices when shopping for Frosty souvenirs. On your next visit to Put-in-Bay, take a piece of Frostys with you back to your Put-in-Bay campsite!

  • 978 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
  • 419-285-2811


The Put-in-Bay wine that has been grown and bottled locally can be found here, at Heineman’s Winery Crystal Cave Gift Shop. There is a great selection of Island white, red and sparkling wines, as well as grape juice for the youngsters. There is also a handsome assortment wine-related gifts. From the vine to the wine, Heineman’s Winery at Put-in-Bay is the real deal!

Photo of shopping for cigars with Lake Erie Tobacconist
  • Website NONE

  • 1400 Catawba Avenue Toledo Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-366-5681


The Lake Erie Tobacconist is the man to see for those seeking the finest cigars available at Put-in-Bay and perhaps all of the Lake Erie Islands. His selection of Put-in-Bay Inspired Cigars are personally selected by him and many are hand rolled in the Dominican Republic.

  • 160 Thompson Road, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456

  • 330-608-4664


The Keys Restaurant is home to Jessie’s Jewelry and offers quality, handmade works of art that you can wear proudly. Jessie Green is a craftswoman who specializes in sterling silver dragonflies, butterflies, and other beautifully crafted nature forms. These items are truly one-of-a-kind, and a great treasure to take home when shopping on the Lake Erie Islands.

Photo of a place to go shopping called Lovella
  • 258 Delaware Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-5010


Offering the finest apparel and accessories, Lovella has the right options for the fashion conscious. Featuring a wide selection of upscale swimsuits, sunglasses and chic clothing from well-known designers. Open late to better serve you. Be sure to include Lovella Fashion Apparel while you are sightseeing at Put-in-Bay.

Photo of Mariners Locker Sopping at Put-in-Bay
  • 204 Hartford Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-7005


Ahoy! At the Mariner’s Locker you’ll find wonderful nautical menswear for the boaters and water fanatics alike. The shop is located on Hartford Ave. next to The Boathouse Bar and Grill, just a half of block from the Jet Express Dock. Come and check out the great offerings at the Mariner’s Locker before setting sail from Put-in-Bay.

Photo of the Misty Bay Boutique A place for great shopping!
  • 210 Delaware Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
  • 419-285-7925


Treat yourself to the best at The Misty Bay Boutique in downtown Put-in-Bay. The fashionable offerings include Columbia Sportswear, Sebago Shoes and an assortment of nautically inspired apparel. Look for this chic shopping spot next to The Roundhouse Bar.

Picture of Mr. Ed's Clothing for sale.
  • 272 Delaware Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-3101


Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill is a must stop for anyone visiting Put-in-Bay and the Lake Erie Islands. Come and find some of the most unique t-shirts, hats and sweatshirts the island has to offer. Many bear Mr. Ed’s famous slogan, “Nobodys Ugly after 2.” Support your favorite Put-in-Bay bar with some Mr. Ed’s gear!

Photo of Perry's Cave Gift shop a place for Put-in-Bay Shopping
  • 979 Catawba Ave., Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-2405


On Catawba Ave. you’ll find Perry’s Family Fun Center. Within the complex is this great shop that specializes in nature and cave related gifts and artifacts. Here you can purchase a rough mix bag of gems and take your chances on finding that special stone. Also, there is candy and toys for the children while enjoying their Put-in-Bay adventure.

Photo of Put-in-Bay Shopping location the Island Surf Shop
  • 405 Catawba Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456



Want to look hot while you’re out at the Bay? Put-in-Bay Surf Shop has what you need. Find men’s and women’s bathing suits, shoes, board shorts, dresses, purses, jewelry and bags by favorite brands Quicksilver, Billabong, Roxy, Oakley, Rusty, Reef and more. Trendy, So Cal style that’s perfect for island life.

Picture of the Put-in-Bay Trading Co
  • 441 Catawba Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-3333


Located next to Town Hall and the PIB Police, The Put-in-Bay Trading Co. has an impressive assortment of novelty t-shirts and shorts. Most of their neat designs reflect on Put in Bay and the grandeur of the Lake Erie islands. They are a licensed Orange County Chopper merchandiser, providing gifts for all of the bikers in your family. Come to the Put-in-Bay Trading Co. and get your PIB gear.

Photo of shopping at the Put-in-Bay T Shirt Company
  • Website-None

  • 220 Hartford Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-7006


The Put-in-Bay T-shirt shop is a shop that is hard to miss in the downtown Put-in-Bay landscape. A giant shirt outlined in lights welcomes visitors to check out the variety of shirts and gifts. Conveniently located less than a block from the Jet-Express Dock, the Put-in-Bay T-Shirt Shop has got the apparel for you.

Picture of shopping for sunglasses at Sunstoppers
  • 161-197 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-7777


Protect yourself from the Put-in-Bay sun with a pair of shade’s from Sunstopper’s. Located on Delaware Ave. near the Boathouse Bar and Grill, there are many name brand styles to choose from. Popular brands such as Maui Jim, Oakley and Ray-Ban highlight the offerings. So stop squinting and focus in at Sunstopper’s on Put-in-Bay.

  • 341 Bayview Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-3695


The Lobster Trap is the gift shop for the Boardwalk family of restaurants. The shop features apparel, home goods, and Boardwalk brand products. They are well known for their Lobster Bisque, Bloody Mary Mix, and Cocktail sauces, all of which you can purchase to take home with you as a memento of your Put-in-Bay Vacation 

Picture of Wharfside a place for shopping at Put-in-Bay
  • 361 Bayview Avenue Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

  • 419-285-4511


Boating on the Lake Erie Islands is a favorite activity of many. Shopping for your Put-in-Bay Boating needs? The Wharfside is equipped to serve you. Life jackets, buoys, and warning lights are available for your craft and bait and tackle for the anglers in your family. Ohio Fishing licenses can be purchased for your Put-in-Bay fishing trip. A variety of snacks and drinks are also available.